politics is to want something

fredag, november 04, 2005

the most successful society the world has ever known

Maybe its because I am nervous that California will put the axe to unions and take huge a step backward on women's rights in next Tuesday's election, but I've been cheering myself up by trying to follow social democratic politics in Europe. Here is a great article in UK's Guardian Online about Sweden. Well worth a read. Here's also a nice summary and response on Peter Gustavsson's great blog.

I hate to contribute to the myth that our friends in Europe have solved all their problems, or that, somehow, Europeans are just better than Americans. They aren't. You'll find much of the same small-mindedness, xenophobia and selfishness over there as over here. What you will also find, however, is a political culture which was transformed by a powerful and innovative labor movement. Toynbee's article in the Guardain undermphasizes this.

While cultural differences are important, I've always held that the major differences between Europe and the United States in terms of political culture are historical and political. Some of them rise to the level of structure: the lack of feudal past, the legacy of slavery and white supremacy, the long period of expansion into the west, etc. However, all politics is about confronting structure with agency- adapting to the conditions presented to you and willfully pursuing a course of action. Politics, indeed, is to want something.

We can build a successful society here in the United States. Our historically vibrant social movements have long been inspirational to those struggling in the rest of the world. Olaf Palme, one of the architects of Swedish social democracy, was profoundly inspired by the time he spent in the United States, and considered himself a student of civil rights insurgencies here. We, too can be inspired by the successes, however under attack and in retreat, of our friends in colder climes, but we must never forget that our own path will be different. Most importantly, actually existing social democracy is an argument that there are different ways to organize society. So often, our opponents on the right seem to convince us that their way is the only way available. A better world is possible. However, an American "successful society" will be distinctly American.

Let us continue.

3 Comments:

Anonymous Anonym said...

'We can build a successful society here in the United States.'

Too late, bud.

A little knowledge of U.S. history amply reveals that when someone who could improve things actually comes along he faces either inveterate opposition (like Roosevelt, who didn't accomplish a fraction of what he could have accomplished in four terms) or, worse, he gets murdered (JFK, RFK).

The right has essentially set things up over the last 25 years so Americans wouldn't know a sensible social or economic policy if one hit them in the face.

Add to that that the country may never have another real election.

Social Democracy Now
http://www.blogigo.co.uk/socialdemocracynow

fredag, november 04, 2005 11:23:00 p.m.

 
Blogger daraka kenric said...

So, I guess we should all pack up and go home, then.

Indeed, a little knowlege of US history reveals a startling list of compromises and failures. However, a little more knowlege also reveals tremendous surges and steps forward. It's true that Roosevelt didn't accomplish as much as the left would have wanted, but he also accomplished what he did only because of organizing and hard work on the ground. And those accomplishments were not insignificant.

Yes, the past 25 years have been disastrous overall. I, for one, am not willing to simply throw in the towel.

"Pessimism of the Intellect, Optimisim of the Will."

lørdag, november 05, 2005 9:18:00 a.m.

 
Blogger gkurtz said...

Daraka, you say: "However, an American 'successful society' will be distinctly American." That makes sense, but I want to know what you mean by it. To the extent we can guess these things in advance, what are the distinctively American things about an American social democratic (or whatever you want to call it) model?

By the way: Congrats on defeating the ballot measures!

onsdag, november 09, 2005 6:03:00 a.m.

 

Legg inn en kommentar

<< Home